I once negotiated a 2-year contract for a player on £200,000 per year.
I’d clearly explained the offer multiple times, but he’d understood it as £200,000 over the 2 years - so £100,000 per year, and was still delighted to sign at those numbers.
Then when it came to the actual signing of the contract, he was shocked and delighted to see the real number i'd negotiated for him. He signed it and only told me afterwards that it was double what he thought he was signing for.
That season he didn't do too badly, had a few injuries but played quite well in some of the games. Nothing special.
But this is the psychological reality of some players. By the end of that season, he’d forgotten all about the perspective he had at the beginning.
He’d heard that some of the best international players at the club were on £250,000, so he thought he should be on £250,000 too. (Side note: changing room banter puts everyone’s wage 20 to 50% higher than it really is.)
The reality is he was nowhere near the level of those international players, even though the bubble of his own hubris made him think he was.
whilst I didn’t outright disagree with him. I did point out that there were some incredible players at that club, reminded him he’d been delighted to sign for what he thought was £100,000 when he walked in, and asked him what had changed in the 12 months since that day. Then I told him:
Look, you’re out of contract at the end of next season. The market will tell us whether you’re underpaid or not.
As I expected, we scoured the market from 1 July of his final season (that’s when we start discussing free transfers in rugby), and nobody wanted to sign him even at £200,000, let alone £250,000. What the market was actually telling us was that he was overpaid rather than underpaid.
In the end, we had to move him back to his previous club outside the UK.
There’s a name for this: the hedonic treadmill. You get used to what you have pretty quickly, and then it’s just the baseline. One of my first bosses had warned me about the agent’s version of this many years earlier. Sign a player a great 3-year deal, and this is what happens:
Season 1: they’re so grateful.
Season 2: they think you did an ok job.
Season 3: they think you undersold them, and it was a poor deal all along.
Memories of circumstances are short.
Here’s how I manage it as an athlete manager:
I’m grateful that with most of my players, we have a very honest and open dialogue. It’s just the way I’ve always been, but I also seem to be drawn to that type of player. So I’m straight with them from the start:
I may think you’re a £300,000 player, you may think you’re a £300,000 player, but if the clubs don’t, we've got our work cut out for us.
You can be the best negotiator in the world, but ultimately if our parameters of a good deal and a bad deal don’t cross over with the clubs' brackets at any point, we need to go and find another club. And if there isn’t another club at those numbers, it shows you we were both a bit delusional in the first place.
📊 Data helps now as well. You can put a player’s numbers on the table (goals, tries, minutes, whatever the sport counts) next to the players they’re comparing themselves to, and there’s an objectivity to it that the conversation never used to have.
💡 Lesson: a player is only underpaid if another club is willing to pay them more.